We read each vendor’s own pages: homepage, product pages, pricing and any published research. For every criterion an agent gets one of three marks:
- Documented (2 points): the vendor explains how it works, specifically enough that you could test it.
- Mentioned (1 point): the vendor says it does this, without saying how.
- Not found (0 points): we could not find it on the vendor’s pages. That does not prove the product lacks it; it means you have to ask.
Agents are ordered by their total out of ten. Ties go to the agent with the stronger human review mark, then the stronger send-layer safety mark, because those two decide what happens when the agent is wrong.
We do not use vendor case-study numbers, review-site ratings or analyst quadrants, and we do not give scores for writing quality: models write well enough, and the failures that cost pipeline are stale facts, uneven runs and missing guardrails. Every mark links back to the vendor pages it came from, on each agent’s profile.
What the ranking is not
It is not a head-to-head lab test of every product. Running each agent on the same accounts over repeated runs is the strongest evidence there is, and it is the test we recommend you run on your own shortlist: how to test an AI sales agent on real pipeline outcomes.
When it changes
Vendors ship fast. At each review we re-read every source, update marks and prices, and change the “last reviewed” date. A vendor that publishes new evidence for a criterion moves up as soon as we have read it.